- Here are the Recipes I used: I made the Banana Cream Pie I recipe from All Recipes. That recipe is essentially the same as this one. Pretty easy work! We didn’t have any whipped cream, but that recipe uses egg yolks… leaving us with egg whites. This Better Homes & Gardens article about how to make meringue for pies provided instructions that worked perfectly! I thought it odd that the All Recipes pie recipe called for baking the pie, but once I added meringue, it made perfect sense to do so.